• About Moi?

blogsense-by-barb

~ at the Re-Birth of America!

blogsense-by-barb

Daily Archives: 01/09/2013

Debunking the Common Core “The Emperor’s New Clothes” Narrative….

09 Wednesday Jan 2013

Posted by blogsense-by-barb in America, Articles, Big Government, blogsense, censorship/political correctness, Community interest, Current Events, education, Family values, FREEDOM, government, Parenting, People, Poetry

≈ 2 Comments

Tags

AAASA Journal of Scholarship and Practice, Benchmarking for Success, Christopher H. Tienken, Common Core State Standards

Debunking the Common Core “The Emperor’s New Clothes” Narrative…

emperor-has-no-clothes

…and why are education reformers/politicians ascribing to fairy tales for policy?

by Gretchen Logue

Should Common Core State Standards (CCSS) be considered an educational version of the story “The Emperor’s New Clothes”? The standards are the promise of new clothes for education but is there basis for believing there are any clothes at all? From Wikipedia:

    “The Emperor’s New Clothes” (Danish: Kejserens nye Klæder) is a short tale by Hans Christian Andersen about two weavers who promise an Emperor a new suit of clothes that is invisible to those unfit for their positions, stupid, or incompetent. When the Emperor parades before his subjects in his new clothes, a child cries out, “But he isn’t wearing anything at all!” The tale has been translated into over a hundred languages.[1]

Christopher H. Tienken, Editor of AAASA Journal of Scholarship and Practice provided commentary in the Winter 2011 publication entitled Common Core State Standards: An Example of Data-less Decision Making.

His research may just expose the standards to be unfit and fallacy to those who are critical thinkers asking for data determining their stated validity. This article should be studied by educators, politicians, taxpayers, to understand the colossal farce Common Core standards are in terms of providing promises of educational improvement for American students as they are unproven and untested.

Tienken writes the standards have not been validated empirically and no metric has been set to monitor the intended and unintended consequences they will have on the education system and children (Mathis, 2010). So why would governors and private trade organizations spend millions of taxpayer dollars on theories instead of verifiable researched data? The CCSS proponents have bought into these two arguments:

  • America’s children are “lagging” behind international peers in terms of academic achievement, and
  • the economic vibrancy and future of the United States relies upon American students outranking their global peers on international tests of academic achievement because of the mythical relationship between ranks on those tests and a country’s economic competitiveness.

Where’s the data supporting the CCSS proponents’ arguments? There isn’t much put forth by the education reformers. So why are states and school districts implementing unproven and untested theories? He defines the acceptance/lack of data for the unproven and untested CCSS assessments and implementation allegedly designed to enable students to become “globally competitive” with such sentences/phrases as:

  • An unbelievable suspension of logic and evidence
  • To believe that economic strength of the United States relies on how students rank on the Trends in International Math and Science Study (TIMSS) or the Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA), rather than reliance on policy (tax, trade, health, labor, finance, monetary, housing, natural resources policy)… “is like believing in the tooth fairy”
  • The “critical skills necessary to compete in the 21st century” are repackaged 19th century ideas and skills…they are “inert, sterile, socially static”…the CCSS are stuck in a curricular time machine set in 1858
  • Connecting an individual’s education achievement on a standardized test to a nation’s economic future is not empirically or logically acceptable and using that mythical connection for large-scale policymaking is civically reckless … when school administrators implement programs and policies built on those faulty arguments, they commit education malpractice
  • More countries with national standards underperformed the US than did countries without national standards
  • To think that every student in this country should be made to learn the same thing is illogical—it lacks face validity … we should have learned from the Soviet Union that central planning does not work in the long-run
  • Standardization and testing are so entrenched in Singapore that every attempt to diversity the system has failed, leaving Singapore a country that has high test scores but no creativity
  • (CCSS) creates a standardizing apparatus…we should respect differences among children, not try to extinguish them…there is a lot more going on here on the societal level than meets the eye … it’s more complex than the creators and vendors of the standards either understand or wish to present
  • Children have a right to a quality education. School leaders, those who prepare them, and the people who lead our professional organizations have a duty to help provide the quality … if some education leaders choose to drink the snake oil then they should expect to get sick. If some help sell it, they should resign.

He backs up his findings with 48 independent referenced sources. It is worth your time to read his commentary that destroys the CCSS proponents’ arguments with methodical precision based on actual data. Compare/contrast his research/reference with the data CCSSO and the NGA use:

“Many school districts or schools have “data committees” that make school-widedecisions based on some type of data. Surely there must be quality data available publically to support the use of the CCSS to transform, standardize, centralize and essentially delocalize America’s public education system. The official website for the CCSS claims to provide such evidence. The site alleges that the standards are “evidence based” and lists two homegrown documents to “prove” it: Myths vs Facts (NGA, 2010) and the Joint International Benchmarking Report (NGA, 2008).

“The Myths document presents claims that the standards have “made use of a large and growing body of knowledge” (p. 3). Knowledge derives in part from carefully controlled scientific experiments and observations so one would expect to find references to high quality empirical research to support the standards.

“When I reviewed that “large and growing body of knowledge” offered by the NGA, I found that it was not large, and in fact built mostly on one report, Benchmarking for Success, created by the NGA and the CCSSO, the same groups that created these standards; Hardly independent research.

The Benchmarking report has over 135 end notes, some of which are repetitive references. Only four of the cited pieces of evidence could be considered empirical studies related directly to the topic of national standards and student achievement.

The remaining citations were newspaper stories, armchair magazine articles, op-ed pieces, book chapters, notes from telephone interviews, and several tangential studies.

Many of the citations were linked to a small group of standardization advocates and did not represent the larger body of empirical thought on the topic”.

Tienken’s report needs to be sent to school boards, superintendents, state educational agencies, educational reform groups, governors and state legislators for their response to his research and conclusions. These private and/or public entities need to asked why they support common core standards and provide the data to back up their beliefs and use of the standards. If you get shocked faces and declarations from these groups/politicians such as “I do whatever _________ tells me to” (fill in the blank: state agency, federal government, governor, etc), you know the right to direct your school’s educational direction is in dire jeopardy.

Read more HERE

Advertisement

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest

Like this:

Like Loading...

Best Research Award Winner Says Common Core is Data-less Decision Making

09 Wednesday Jan 2013

Posted by blogsense-by-barb in America, Attitudes, blogsense, censorship/political correctness, Community interest, education, Family values, FREEDOM, government, Parenting, People, politics

≈ 1 Comment

Tags

AASA Journal of Scholarship and Practice, Christopher Tienken, Common Core Standards, Institute of Education Sciences

Best Research Award Winner Says Common Core is Data-less Decision Making

Dr-TienkenChristopher Tienken, Ed.D. is the editor of the AASA Journal of Scholarship and Practice. He is an assistant professor of Education Administration at Seton Hall University. He has public school administration experience as a PK-12 assistant superintendent, middle school principal, and elementary school assistant principal. He began his career in education as an elementary school teacher. Dr Tienken’s research interests include the effect and influence of professional development on teacher practice and student achievement, the construct validity of high-stakes standardized tests as decision-making tools about student achievement and school effectiveness, and curricular interventions used in schools to improve achievement. His research about the effects of professional development on student achievement has been recognized by the Institute of Education Sciences and the National Staff Development Council awarded him the Best Research Award in 2008.”

As a top researcher in academic practice and student achievement, Dr. Tienken looked at the claims of those who support the Common Core Standards and wrote about his findings in the Winter 2011 edition of the Journal of Scholarship & Practice. You can read his full report “Common Core State Standards: An Example of Data-less Decision Making” here. What follows are some key highlights from it.

On the claim that the standards are evidence based and internationally benchmarked.

    “The standards have not been validated empirically and no metric has been set to monitor the intended and unintended consequences they will have on the education system and children (Mathis, 2010)”

    “The site alleges that the standards are “evidence based” and lists two homegrown documents to “prove” it: Myths vs Facts (NGA, 2010) and the Joint International Benchmarking Report (NGA, 2008).

    common core 2013The Myths document presents claims that the standards have “made use of a large and growing body of knowledge” (p. 3). Knowledge derives in part from carefully controlled scientific experiments and observations so one would expect to find references to high quality empirical research to support the standards.

    When I reviewed that “large and growing body of knowledge” offered by the NGA, I found that it was not large, and in fact built mostly on one report, Benchmarking for Success, created by the NGA and the CCSSO, the same groups that created these standards; Hardly independent research.”

The need for the standards has been justified by claiming that, (a) America’s children are “lagging” behind international peers in terms of academic achievement, and (b) the economic vibrancy and future of the United States relies upon American students outranking their global peers on international tests of academic achievement.

Tienken’s response –

brainwash2“Unfortunately for proponents of this empirically vapid argument it is well established that a rank on an international test of academic skills and knowledge does not have the power to predict future economic competitiveness and is otherwise meaningless for a host of reasons (Baker, 2007; Bracey, 2009; Tienken, 2008).”

He sites these examples to support his statement.

    “The fact is China and its continued manipulation of its currency, the Yuan, and iron-fisted control of its labor pool, has a greater effect on our economic strength than if every American child scored at the top of every international test, the SAT, the ACT, the GRE, or the MAT.” (emphasis added)

    “Japan‘s stock market, the Nikkei 225 Average, closed at a high of 38,915 points on December 31, 1989 and on October 15, 2010 it closed at 9,500 points, approximately 75% lower, but Japan ranked in the Top 10 on international tests of mathematics since the 1980‘s and has always ranked higher than the U.S. on such tests. Yet Japan‘s stock market and its economy have been in shambles for almost two decades. They have national curriculum standards and testing, and have for over 30 years. Japanese students outrank students from most other nations on math and science tests.”

    “Economic strength of the G20 countries relies more on policy, than education achievement.”

    “To believe otherwise is like believing in the tooth-fairy.”

Even if the standards were a good idea, they would not lead to the results that their proponents promise. Given their tremendous cost, it seems reasonable to question whether they are really needed. At the very least we should ask, is this a good investment of America’s capital?

READ MORE HERE

multiple-intelligencesBLOGGER’S NOTE: As an educator, it is just plain foolishness to think any kind of collectivity, lumping all students into one giant classroom, dispensing pre-designed curricula and calling it Common Core Standards is simply idiotic! YES, our education system needs some serious help, but this is over-simplifying the problem AND an imagined solution. Nothing short of a radical re-design of what curriculum means and how to TEACH individual students (rather than “groups” of children) is going to improve the learning curve in American schools! Collectivity is NOT the answer in education any more than it is in anything else. As much as Americans want to believe in equality, we must understand that equality does NOT refer to our individual giftings and abilities. In those, we are divinely created unique individuals!

Share this:

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Email
  • Print
  • More
  • Reddit
  • Tumblr
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest

Like this:

Like Loading...

Search BlogsensebyBarb

Honor our Fallen

Click EVERYDAY to Support our Vets!

Help Veterans! The Veterans Site

Top Posts & Pages

  • Ft. Ligonier, PA - The Blustery British vs French Battle Young Gen Washington lost!
  • Where is the War on Women? Right HERE!
  • A D-Day Mourning
  • The Skewed War Against Women?
  • 30 Seconds of Wisdom From Coca Cola CEO
  • Proposed 28th Amendment to the United States Constitution
  • Romney's "Gay Old Party" ?
  • How Does Obama's Gay Marriage Stance Affect Military?
  • Living Life After Iraq
  • What is Left? What is Right?

History of Posts

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 963 other subscribers

ACT NOW! GET INVOLVED!


Visit Tea Party Command Center

Project 365 Vets

FACEBOOK CONNECTION

Barbara Brison

Create Your Badge

To Tweet or Not to Tweet!

  • The #1 reason I choose. AMAC is that it competes with AARP which was so much apart of Obamacare!blogsensebybarb 3 years ago
  • RT @newtgingrich: My typing is sometimes wrong but the principle is timeless in the American system. Mueller (note correct spelling) had a…blogsensebybarb 3 years ago
  • RT @realDonaldTrump: Nothing changes from the Mueller Report. There was insufficient evidence and therefore, in our Country, a person is in…blogsensebybarb 3 years ago
  • RT @tedcruz: As the son of a Cuban immigrant whose Dad came to get a math degree & become a computer programmer, I’m troubled that Dems see…blogsensebybarb 3 years ago
  • RT @newtgingrich: I want to reemphasize a key part of the American system. You are innocent until proven guilty. The left wants to reverse…blogsensebybarb 3 years ago
  • @StupidPlain @itsJeffTiedrich @realDonaldTrump When the truth is revealed, you will be disgraced, unless the media picks up the song.vblogsensebybarb 3 years ago
Follow @BrisonVoice

Americans Stand with Israel!

Flight 93 Memorial Design

Never Forget!!!!!!!

Photobucket Thanks, Cap'n Bob & the Damsel for helping us remember!

Blogroll

  • 2012 Patriot
  • America's Watchtower
  • American Thinker
  • American Veteran Magazine
  • Bare Naked Islam
  • Be Kind Rewrite
  • Be sure you are right, then go ahead
  • BLACKFIVE
  • Boudica BPI Weblog
  • Breitbart
  • Cassie's Perfect … Word
  • Citizen Tom
  • CITIZENS UNITED
  • Come in and Soak Awhile
  • Conservative News Central
  • Creeping Sharia
  • Dedicated To Heroes
  • Diary of a Mad Conservative
  • Doug Ross @ Journal
  • Fatherly Advice and RANTS
  • Fellowship of the Minds
  • Find an Outlet
  • Freedom, by the Way
  • Gds44's Blog
  • Green Mountain Scribes
  • Grumpy Opinions
  • I Hate the Media
  • Infidel Bloggers Alliance
  • It Makes Sense Blog
  • Jlthomson’s Blog
  • loopyloo305
  • LORINOV'S BLOG
  • Maggie’s Notebook
  • MICHELLE OBAMA'S MIRROR
  • My Facebook
  • Nice Deb
  • Now the End Begins
  • Oath Keepers
  • Proud Military Mom's Common Sense Blog
  • pumabydesign001's blog
  • Radio Patriot
  • Reclaim America Now!
  • Right Side News
  • Rogue Operator
  • Ron McGatlin
  • Samuel at Gilgal
  • SilenceDogood2010′s Blog
  • Socialism is Not the Answer
  • Sword At-The-Ready
  • The American Civil Rights Union
  • The American Conservative
  • The Conservatory
  • The Constitution Club
  • The Free Market Project
  • The Imaginative Conservative
  • The Last Refuge
  • The Liberty Tree
  • The Mad Jewess
  • The Patriot Factor
  • The Political War Zone
  • The Quest for Light
  • The Unknown Soldiers
  • The Western Experience
  • Tombo's World
  • USO
  • Velvetdreams Mindsay
  • VETERAN DEFENDERS OF AMERICA
  • Voting American
  • Wild Goose Festival
  • You Decide
  • ~ BLOGGER.GUNNY.G.1984+ ~ (BLOG & EMAIL)

PROUD of ALL Who SERVE!!!!

VETERANS Make the Connection

Our Star-Spangled Banner

Supporters of the US Constitution

TEA Party Member

Click for Bill of Rights

Please Pray for Our Troops

Versatile Blogger Award

January 2013
M T W T F S S
 123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
28293031  
« Dec   Feb »

Thousands of Deadly Islamic Terror Attacks Since 9/11

Support Wounded Warriors

Let’s Fight FOCA Together!

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

Privacy & Cookies: This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this website, you agree to their use.
To find out more, including how to control cookies, see here: Cookie Policy
  • Follow Following
    • blogsense-by-barb
    • Join 510 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • blogsense-by-barb
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: